Tag

Peer Review

Every CitationLab post tagged peer review. A small collection for now; it grows as the topic recurs.

Guides

"Your literature is outdated" — a triage plan

Eight words of feedback with four possible meanings, and only one is answered by adding recent citations. How to work out which comment you received, which references are supposed to be old, and what to fix first.

Read the post →
For Institutions

How journal editors raise REFerence [IN]tegrity before publication

Peer review checks the science; copy-editing checks the format. Nobody checks that the references resolve. Where a reference screen belongs in a journal pipeline, and why it belongs at the desk screen.

Read the post →